Israeli Flag Scottish Friends of Israel Redressing the Balance

 Home   About Scottish Friends of Israel - Useful Links - Contact

Security Issues


Gaza Demolitions
- Saving Lives

Aaron Lerner Date: 16 May 2004

The Supreme Court ruled this morning to permit the IDF to widen the Philadelphi Corridor. The Philadelphi Corridor separates between Egypt and the Gaza Strip. As Chief of Staff Moshe (Bugi) Yaalon told the cabinet today, Egypt is not acting to stop the flow of weapons from Egypt to the Gaza Strip - weapons that frequently are used to attack Israel within the Green Line. Thus Israel finds itself with no choice but to act to stop the smuggling itself.

The buildings adjacent to the patrol road of the Philadelphi Corridor are currently close enough that patrols and monitoring posts on the Corridor are within range of a broad array of weapons now commonly held by the Palestinians.

Widening the corridor will put Palestinian forces out of range if they want to attack while taking cover.

1. The monitoring posts, that will be beyond the range of the bulk (if not
all) of Palestinian fire can be expected to also be more effective as the soldiers in the observation posts will not be distracted by constant incoming fire trying to kill them.

2. The buildings that are to be removed also made it possible for Palestinians to place bombs on the patrol road without detection as the buildings were so close to the road - removal of these buildings makes it considerably more difficult for Palestinian explosives teams to position bombs on the road as they will have to traverse an open area that is being monitored.

3. Putting the patrol road belong firing range also means that operations on the road to detect and destroy smuggling tunnels will be able to focus on doing their job without the constant distraction - as well as hindrance - caused by ongoing Palestinian efforts to kill them.

4. In addition to making the patrol road more effective and saving Israeli and Palestinian lives (since Palestinian civilians will no longer be serving as human shields for Palestinian attackers in the area adjacent to the patrol road) a significant widening of the Corridor will make tunnel construction considerably more costly and easier to detect; More costly because of the longer distances that have to be traversed. Easier to detect because the equipment required for the construction of the longer tunnels will be more sophisticated and its presence will be more readily detectable.

Of course, if Egypt should ever decide that it wants to stop the smuggling (its treaty with Israel places no limit on the size of the armed police force that can operate on the border) they will have an even easier time stopping the operation because of the equipment and other demands created by the extension of the distance required before smuggling tunnels from Egypt can surface under the cover of Palestinian buildings in the Gaza Strip.

None of this would be necessary if Egypt had honored its treaty obligations to Israel to stop the flow of weapons across its border. But, unfortunately, while Jordan has even at times sent people to jail for trying to send weapons from Jordan to the Palestinians, the Egyptians decline to act.

The debate over the buildings serves to expose the false moral stand of many retreat supporters who claim that they support retreat to save Israeli lives.

The moment that these same retreat supporters take the position that Palestinian bricks are more important than Israeli blood they have essentially forfeited their claim that they are driven by a desire to save Israeli lives.

Dr. Aaron Lerner, Director IMRA (Independent Media Review & Analysis)


IMRA - Independent Media Review and Analysis



Web Design surfgate7 - copyright: MRG ©2003